Jury selection in the trial of a man accused of murdering his wife and the mother of his four children began this week. The accused, James Morris Lynn, Jr., 42, is charged with murder, felony murder and aggravated assault in connection with the death of Tonya Faye Royster Lynn, who was reported missing on July 27, 2011. Her body was discovered in a well two days later.
On Monday, 47 men and women were led into the courtroom and were questioned over the course of the day. The selection took place in courtroom four of the Barrow County Superior Courthouse before Piedmont Judicial Circuit's Honorable Joseph Booth. By 4:30 p.m., a panel of 12 jurors and two alternates were selected.
Jurors were asked to return to the courthouse at 9 a.m. on Tuesday. Booth instructed them not to discuss the case with anyone, nor to post anything on their Facebook or Twitter accounts relating to their jury service.
“Go home, get a good night's rest, and come back at 9 a.m,” said Booth. “Come with an open mind and follow the direction of the bailiffs.”
When asked by one of the jury members how long the trial is expected to last, Booth said he did not anticipate it taking longer than the rest of this week.
When potential jurors were led into the courtroom just after 10 a.m. Monday, Lynn had sat unshackled, dressed in a beige collared shirt, tie and black slacks. During the judge’s instructions and during introductions, all the attorneys faced the panelists. Defendant Lynn sat to the left of his attorneys and closed his eyes and kept his head down for much of the process.
All potential jurors were sworn in under oath prior to questioning and then were read Lynn’s official indictment, stating that a grand jury found sufficient evidence to indict Lynn on charges alleging that he hit Tonya Lynn over the head with a baseball bat, killing her, in July 2011.
During the process of “voir dire”, lawyers get to question the jury and move to strike the members who appear biased or partial.
Barrow County District Attorney Brad Smith questioned the crowd in less than 30 minutes. One of his questions related to whether any panelist had ever been involved in a heated divorce. None of the jurors answered positively to that question.
Lynn's defense attorney Arnold “Beau” Kaye, took significantly less time with voir dire. He asked if any of them had seen any news accounts involving the charges against Lynn. Several jurors answered that they had heard about the case in the news, but none of them indicated that it could sway their ability to come to a fair and impartial judgment.
Had the state been seeking the death penalty, the panel of jurors would have to be “death qualified,” which is bad for a defendant, as it tends to select for highly conservative people. However, Lynn’s charges do not qualify him to be a candidate for the death penalty.
Last week, during a pre-trial motions hearing, Booth denied a request by Lynn's defense attorneys to suppress a recorded confession Lynn made to Winder Police investigators and GBI agents who were working the case prior to the discovery of Tonya Lynn’s body, which was found in a well off Ethridge Road in Auburn.
Check back for updates.
I guess bashing the head of your wife with a baseball bat, lying about it, ditching her down a well is just enough for life, but then again, who knows how the Barrow circus of courts will handle this