Tuesday’s unexpected failure of Barrow County’s proposed spending plan for fiscal year 2012 has led to a high-stakes political battle that is being played out behind the scenes and will culminate at a called meeting Monday of the Barrow County Board of Commissioners.
District 1 Commissioner Larry Joe Wilburn fired the first shot early Friday by issuing a proposal that calls for eight percent cuts in the public safety budgets of the Sheriff’s Office, the Barrow County Detention Center and Barrow County Emergency Services – including fire, EMS and Emergency 911 services.
It also suggests cutting the other county departments’ budgets by five percent and reducing by 10 percent all spending on fuel.
The proposal states it would be up to elected officials and managers to get their departments through the new fiscal year with whatever money is appropriated and to implement “furloughs, hiring freeze, shorter work weeks, watching all expenditures (such as gas, supplies, contract work, etc.)”
Wilburn also recommends removal of the entire $600,000 cushion built into the new budget. That funding was recommended by CFO Rose Kisaalita to the budget committee in order to protect the county’s remaining reserves and to start the years-long task of replenishing those emergency funds.
Wilburn’s proposal come weeks after he recommended that the budget committee add an additional one-half mill to the ad valorem tax rate in order to raise about $700,000 for roads and other uses. He said Tuesday night that he voted against the 1.92-mill tax hike recommended by the budget committee because the proposed budget did not have the extra road funding in it.
But Friday morning he wrote that he has “rethought” his ideas about the budget.
“At one time, I was ready to increase the tax on the Citizens of Barrow County to pay for our budget,” he stated. “After talking with numerous people over the county (both young and old) I feel most do not want their taxes raised. Some are having a hard time paying their taxes now.”
Saying his proposal might not be the answer, Wilburn said he offered it as a “talking point on how to balance the budget without increasing taxes.”
He added: “It is, in my opinion, the time to start making the hard decisions. That is what we get the “Big Bucks For”.
SMITH RESPONDS
Two hours after Wilburn’s proposal, Sheriff Jud Smith responded with his own statement.
“I am very disappointed that we have done what the committee has asked us to do, and that is stay with the same budget for the current year. We have done that and the only thing that has increased is retirement and fuel in the amount of $100,000, and the fuel increase was Larry Joe’s idea…”
Smith indicated he believes Wilburn is operating on behalf of Chairman Danny Yearwood, who for the past three years has called for significant cuts to public safety spending.
“I believe after talking to a few commissioners (who voted against the budget committee’s budget) they believe that they have… enabled Danny to get his way now over what most would say is a few dollars in the grand scheme of things,” Smith said.
He said he does not want taxes raised either, but called on public officials and their constituents to look at the issue logically.
“If you want to continue to receive the services you have now – and short-staffed as our government is, the services are minimal now – are you willing to pay an average of $55.00 for an entire year which is roughly a little over a dollar a (week) to keep what you have now?” Smith wrote.
The sheriff said the public should understand that no department manager or elected official requested unneeded extras in the new budget.
“Everything is this budget is necessity to sustain what we have across the board and no one understands,” he said.
Smith said the BOC should have “made the public aware that if it were not for the debt service and property values going down, there would be no increase in the mill rate.”
He asked: “So why put it on the backs of the employees which will have severe consequences in the end to every citizen especially if this outrageous plan is put into motion.”
The sheriff in an interview Friday afternoon said the stakes are high.
“The decisions they make Monday are going to affect every citizen and every visitor of Barrow County in the future. I hope the commissioners realize what’s at stake.”
Commissioner Steve Worley, who has led all three budget processes during the current board’s term, issued his response to Wilburn at 11:22 a.m.
He asked, “Do you have any comments on where to make these cuts in all these departments?”
Worley pointed out that while several cost-cutting suggestions already had been made during the committee’s work on the budget, “the people suggesting these ideas had no cost savings put with them and no follow up.”
Worley added: “The one thing I stated I will vote no on is: furlough days, cutting salaries, (and) raising insurance cost to the employees in the 2012 budget.”
Hit them where it hurts!
Larry Joe has to go in the next election!
It's time to get rid of Barrow only and Winder only governments and combine the two for a savings of millions.
Make your courthouse and admin building part time. Cut all other services but cutting public safety is playing with someones life.
Start the recall right now dumbwood and Larry Joe Wilburn need to go right now !
Sheriff Smith is doing a good job with the budget he is required to live with. Same for the Fire & Emergency Services.
Barrow, you want new businesses to come here and widen the tax base, right? You must have exceptionally well maintained Police and Fire services to motivate businesses to come here.
Privatize the ambulance? Let me see if I can get a response from ya'll after you wait impatiently for a private ambulance to fetch you and get you to medical care. The waits, the delays, the extra protocols all mean lost minutes which means loss of life.
If Barrow were to cut their safety services I would be forced to abandon my home and seek a new residence in a SAFE & SECURE location that understood personal safety is the #1 consideration of RATIONAL people.
Yes, I would hate for my taxes to increase. The current taxes take a big hit on my pay. But, I'd rather cut out cable tv or eat more toast and chicken soup than attempt to survive without the Police & Fire protection I now have.
With that said, Thank You all that serve!
You associated yourself with me when you replied to my post. Your stupidity is ripe; please refrain from name-calling. You must be from elsewhere as well.....gnat is spelled with a g, not a k. You are summarily dismissed from the playground.
Stop calling people names, it's beneath all of us. Add to the debate or shutup.
switching to voluteer Fire dept like Jefferson uses works well also or a paid on call fire dept rather then full time fire fighters.
not letting county employees take home goverment cars or laptops would also make the use by other workers better and increase the use by at least fifty percent when you look how much a county vechile costs and how much is saved by not letting employees rake them home at EOS you can for sure save lots of money by using what is already bought and paid for rather then having items used no more then 30 percent of the time.
not paying EMT and paramedic to just idle wait for calls.
Secondly, switching BACK to a volunteer FD will cost us all more money when the insurance rating drops, not to mention the increased delay in response times affecting a patient's care and/or chance of survival in cases of life or death.
Thirdly, studies have shown it is actually CHEAPER in the long run to buy more vehicles and have them assigned to individuals than it is to rotate their use, otherwise known as "hotseating". The vehicles are better maintained and are not running 24/7. Because of this, they last much longer. If the county was rotating vehicles and not replacing them on a regular basis (which hasn't been done in the past several years), we would have run out of vehicles by now!
Lastly, I don't know how often EMTs and paramedics sit idly, but it seems that may be part of the nature of their business. You can't very well predict when things are going to happen, but when they do, they need to be ready to respond.
Insuranc companies used to fund fire depts and for that matter police.
the insurance companies are delighted not to have to fund these anymore and leave it on taxpayer instead as well as take your insurance money, while using the Police depts to extort premium payments from motorist.
Hotseating just means once the car reaches the 100 k mark sooner not that car have to be bought more. just what is there is used more and less capital outlay.
Other counties are cutting not seeing harmful effects of the cuts.
Major Cities reducing top heavy positions moving the Pork from behind the Desk back out on the street and this is hurting Smaller less top heavy public service with less people taking cars radios and equipment home both rural and metro areas has shown reduction in most crimes reported to the FBI.
surprisingly little effect in positive where there is more money being spent on PUBLIC safety.