To speak with her, 78-year-old Beth Whitehead would not seem a likely threat to national security.
A resident of Barrow County for the past 50 years, Whitehead said she has never been in trouble with anyone, much less with the law.
“I don’t look for trouble. I try to avoid it,” she said.
As it turned out, Whitehead did not have to go looking for trouble – it came looking for her.
Whitehead was home alone last Monday when she received a shocking call. A man identifying himself as an agent with the Department of Homeland Security informed Whitehead that agents were in her yard and ordered her to come out of her house.
“And I said ‘I’m not properly dressed. You’ll have to wait until I change clothes’,” she recalled.
“I didn’t know who they were, what they wanted – I didn’t know anything,” she said.
Whitehead lives on a 90-acre spread off Highway 81. Her house sits 600 yards off the main road.
When she looked out the window, she saw two official looking vehicles parked at the edge of her yard and two men wearing what appeared to be bullet proof vests emblazoned with the acronym I.C.E., short for Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
After Whitehead stepped outside, the two men informed her that she was being investigated as a threat to national security.
Whitehead was surprised to learn that the investigation originated because of a call she had made about the quality of her television reception.
Since the digital transition, Whitehead said the reception on her television has been terrible. She called the maker of her digital converter box in an attempt to get some assistance.
“I have had trouble ever since that box has been installed,” she said.
Unable to solve the problem, the digital box manufacturer recommended she call the FCC (Federal Communications Commission).
Whitehead said she spoke with a very nice lady at the FCC who walked her through everything she needed to do to get better reception.
“She was very, very nice,” Whitehead said. “I thanked her for her help and then I said words to the effect of ‘I would like to shoot the son of a gun that messed up my damn television’,” she said.
“And that was the end of it until they showed up in my yard,” Whitehead said.
“I try to be a good citizen and a good human being and when I was ordered out of my house by someone I did not even know for a reason that I did not know, you cannot believe the shock,” she said. “This was a ridiculous thing that was done to me.”
Before leaving, the agents told Whitehead an investigator would be out to see her.
After the agents left, Whitehead said she went back in her house and cried.
“When I came back in my house and I realized that the federal government had attacked me in my yard, I bawled.”
Whitehead said she has been a good citizen all her life. She believes Homeland Security should have done a background check before launching a full scale investigation.
“I don’t bother a soul,” she said. “I don’t have a speeding ticket, however, I did get one warning about two or three years ago.”
Whitehead added that she has never had a parking ticket, pays her taxes, does her civic duty and is involved in her church.
After the initial shock wore off, fear was replaced by another emotion.
“I got angry that some sons of a gun could come into my yard and talk to me that way,” Whitehead said. “They just came busting out here like a bunch of jackasses.”
Whitehead said she is genuinely surprised that the Department of Homeland Security has so little to do that it would investigate a woman without a blemish in her background.
“I think that Homeland Security should have some more intelligent people working for it,” she said. “I think they’ve got a bunch of damn idiots working for them.”
Though angry about what happened, she remains shaken by the event.
Whitehead is worried her phone line may be tapped and says she has suffered mental anguish and anxiety over the incident.
“For two or three days I stayed in my house and peeped out my windows to see if anybody was in my yard,” she said.
Having investigators return to her house is not Whitehead’s only concern.
“I wonder if I have freedom of speech anymore,” she said. “I am afraid to say anything now.”
Agent Aaron Harward of the Department of Homeland Security said the investigation into Ms. Whitehead has been closed.
“We have a responsibility to investigate all threats and we find out based on our investigation whether or not the threat is credible,” he said.
Harward said people have to be aware that there are certain things you cannot say without prompting an investigation.
Though Whitehead’s original problem has not been resolved, she has no plans to call the FCC again.
“The reception is still awful,” she said.
She did receive some help though. Whitehead said a few days after the incident she received a brochure from the FCC entitled “DTV Made Easy: You Can Do It” explaining what she can do to improve her reception. It did not work.
Whitehead hopes the Homeland Security matter is resolved, but wishes she had asked more questions the day she was investigated as a national security threat.
“When you are totally shocked out of your pants, you don’t see, hear or ask as many questions as you should ask and that’s what happened to me,” she said. “I don’t know when in my entire life I was more shocked than I was that day.”
I'm a bit annoyed that Barrow Journal has stopped posting full version of most stories online. I can't get out every day to get a paper, so I miss quite a bit.
Bought a hugh ranch in Argentina to retire to 'just in case' the living got too rough here. I'm not rich because of that administration and I was not able to buy even a small retirement cabin. How 'bout you?
If the ads on this site were even remotely interesting, I would be happy to support them in that way. I do that on every site I frequent.
TechCrunch and Lifehacker and many other news sites have probably made hundreds from me.
The reporting -- it's changed. I don't feel they go after the hard truth. They are no different the the Barrow County in the sugar coating or biased slant.
As far as money, they could always charge for the online addition. Several of the other newspaper sites I read have been doing that for years.
As far as Bush/Cheney goes, look at the current administration. If you think we are better off with it, then you got more problems than this story not making sense to you.
Mike Buffington
Co-Publisher
Barrow Journal
However, it was the Bush/Cheney crime team that started it violating the civil liberties of Americans who have done nothing wrong. Why are you so willing to give up your freedom under the false pretense of security?
As far as this "story" goes, I doubt Homeland Security started investigating poor old Beth Whitehead on a whim. Im willing to bet her "complaint of poor TV reception" included some sort of threat.
Mike Buffington
Co-Publisher
The idea that a 79 year old couldn't hurt someone is terribly ignorant. There are plenty of people that age who are willing and able to hurt someone if they felt they were right to do so.
The police aren't congress, and the courts have held on many occasions that certain types of speech are not protected.
I could go into more detail on why this is a big deal, and why you need a converter box for old TVs, but that would be very off topic.
This is the incident he is referring to. He did state the facts, but didn't convey the truth. The two situations are similar in the governments over-reaction. But they are also both similar in that both women initially over-reacted themselves and were belligerent to a minor problem.
I am not condoning the government officials in either case. Just as an casual observer, it seemed the officers in both cases were, in the immortal words of our president, acting stupidly. That in no way negates the crazy and hostile behavior of both women.
You act like a crazy person, your gonna get treated like a crazy person.
Remember that old woman a few years ago who took a hammer to the phone of the cable company? Now flash forward a few years and some woman calls up and says she wants to shoot people because of her TV. But storming the house like something off a action movie, yeah stupid.
Without a follow-up investigation, how else would they know Whitehead, although a bit cranky, is otherwise harmless? If they didn't follow up and she actually shot someone, don't you think everyone would be wondering why "no one did anything when she said she would like to shoot someone for messing up her television?
We can't have it both ways. Not with the way people are these days.
That name certainly suits you. There is no defense of what the government thugs did here. I guess you are one of those who supports Bush's Patriots Act. The legislation which violates civil liberties of honest, law-abiding citizens. We are living in dangerous time thanks to the Bush Crime Team.
"We're from the government and we're here to help, with guns."
Mike Buffington
Co-Publisher
Naw, an upstanding and virtuous Christian woman like Miss Whitehead couldn't possibly think she's above the law. Not with her background, breeding and history. You johnny-come-latelies with your tabloid pandering are a laff riot. Thanks for visiting Barrow. You'll be leaving as soon as your paltry ad dollars dry up.
Dear Lord! What a comparison! Cronkite and Buffington? That comparison is a close as he will ever come.